| |
SCOPE OF LIABILITY
The federal government has assumed extensive
liability for personal injuries, death, and property
damage caused by naval vessels or incident to naval
maritime activities. Examples of the specific types of
losses that give rise to admiralty claims include
incidents such as the following:
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Collisions
Swell wash and wake damage
Damage to commercial fishing equipment, beds,
or vessels
Damage resulting from oil spills, paint spray, or
blowing tubes
Damages or injuries to third parties resulting
from a fire or an explosion aboard a naval vessel
Damage to commercial cargo carried in a Navy
bottom
Damage caused by improperly lighted, marked,
or placed buoys or navigational aids for which
the Navy is responsible
Personal injury or death of civilians not
employed by the federal government
(longshoremen, harbor workers, and passengers)
EXCLUSIONS FROM LIABILITY
Certain categories of persons are prevented from
recovering under an admiralty claim for personal injury
or death incurred incident to maritime activities. Such
potential claimants arc compensated under other
statutes.
Such excluded claimants include the
following:
. Military personnel cannot recover for personal
injury, death, or property damage resulting from the
negligent operation of naval vessels, except when they
are injured or killed while aboard a privately owned
vessel that collides with a naval vessel.
. Civil service employees and seamen aboard
Military Sealift Command vessels are limited to
compensation under the Federal Employees
Compensation Act, 5 U.S.C. § 8101-8150 (1982), for
personal injury or death.
MEASURE OF DAMAGES
A survey of damaged property is required in all
collisions and any other maritime incidents involving
potential liability for property damage. Surveys have
been customary in admiralty law and are intended to
eliminate burdensome and difficult questions
concerning proof of damages. Section 1210 of the JAG
Manual has an extensive discussion of survey
procedures.
In personal injury cases, medical examinations are
required for all injured persons. The function of the
medical examination is similar to that of the property
damage survey.
The Secretary of the Navy is authorized to settle
admiralty claims up to $1,000,000, Amounts in excess
of that must be certified to Congress for appropriation.
Certain other officials in the Department of the Navy are
authorizcd to settle admiralty claims for smaller
amounts.
STATUE OF LIMITATIONS
Suits in admiralty must be filed within 2 years after
the incident on which the suit is based. Unlike the
statute of limitations rule under the FTCA, filing an
admiralty claim with the Department of the Navy does
not toll the running of this 2-year period. Nor can the
government administratively waive the statute of
limitations in admiralty cases. If the admiralty claim
cannot be administratively settled within 2 years after
the incident, the claimant must file suit against the
government to prevent the statute of limitations from
running.
PROCEDURES
The procedures for investigating and adjudicating
admiralty claims are explained in sections 1204-1216 of
the JAG Manual. For purposes of this brief introduction
to admiralty claims, the following procedural aspects
are most significant.
The most critical command responsibility in
admiralty cases is to immediately notify JAG and an
appropriate local judge advocate of any maritime
incident that might result in an admiralty claim for, or
against, the government.
Section 1204 of the JAG
Manual gives details concerning the requirement for
immediate reports.
Because of the highly technical,
factual, and legal issues that may be involved in an
admiralty casa, it is absolutely vital that the Admiralty
12-24
|