| |
the 3-day period, neither the date of service nor the
date of trial count. Sundays and holidays do count,
however, in computing the statutory period. If the
accused is served on Wednesday, one must wait
Thursday, Friday, and Saturday before compelling
trial. Trial in this example could not be compelled
before Sunday, and, as a practical matter, not before
Monday. You will find that at U.S. shore estab-
lishments, trials normally do not occur on the week-
ends. However, when ships are at sea or in overseas
ports, a trial is possible at any time and any day of the
week.
The date of service of charges upon the accused is
reflected by the certificate in block 15 at the bottom
of page 2 of the charge sheet. The TC normally exe-
cutes this certificate when he or she presents a copy of
the charge sheet to the accused personally. He or she
must do this even though the accused has previously
been informed of the charges against him or her. This
service of a copy of the charge sheet may also be done
by the command at any time after referral as long as
the service is to the accused personally. Any accused
can lawfully object to participating in trial proceed-
ings before the 3-day waiting period has expired. The
accused may, however, waive the 3-day period, so
long as he or she understands the right and voluntarily
agrees to go to trial earlier.
Pretrial Hearings
After the 3-day period has elapsed, the military
judge may hold sessions of court without members for
the purpose of litigating motions, objections, and
other matters not amounting to a trial of the accuseds
guilt or innocence. The accused may be arraigned and
his or her pleas taken and determined at such a hear-
ing. At such hearings, the judge, TC, DC, accused,
and reporter will be present. Several such hearings
may be held if desired. These hearings are commonly
referred to as Article 39(a) sessions.
Preliminary Matters
At the initial pretrial hearing (Article 39(a) ses-
sion), the first order of business is to incorporate into
the record those documents relating to the convening
of the court and referral of the case for trial. Also all
oaths are administered. The convening order and the
charge sheet and any amendments to either document
become matters of record at this point in the proceed-
ings.
In addition, an accounting of the presence or ab-
sence of those personnel required to be present is
made. This accounting includes all persons named in
the convening order, the counsel, the reporter, and the
military judge. Qualifications of all personnel are
checked for the record.
The Arraignment
The arraignment is the procedure involving the
reading of the charges to the accused and asking for
the accuseds pleas. The actual pleading is not part of
the arraignment. The arraignment is complete when
the accused is asked to enter his or her pleas. This
stage is an important one in the trial because if the
accused voluntarily absents himself or herself without
authority and does not thereafter appear during court
sessions, he or she may nevertheless be tried and, if
the evidence warrants, convicted. The arraignment is
also the cutoff point for the adding of additional
charges to the trial. After arraignment, no new charges
can be added without the consent of the accused.
Motions
At arraignment, the military judge advises the
accused that his or her pleas are about to be requested
and that if he or she desires to make any motions he
or she should now do so. Many times all such motions
(attacking jurisdiction, sufficiency of charges, illegal
pretrial confinement, and speedy trial) will have al-
ready been litigated at a previous pretrial hearing.
Nevertheless, the accused may decide to make addi-
tional motions and is allowed to do so. If there are
motions, they are litigated at this time. If there are no
motions, the trial proceeds to the arraignment.
Pleas
The arraignment is the process of asking the ac-
cused to plead to charges and specifications. The re-
sponses of the accused to each specification and
charge are known as the pleas. The recognized pleas
in military practice are guilty, not guilty, guilty to a
lesser included offense, and, under some circum-
stances, a conditional plea of guilty. Any other pleas
(such as nolo contendere) are improper, and the mili-
tary judge enters a plea of not guilty for the accused.
NOT GUILTY PLEAS. When not guilty pleas
are entered by the court or accused, the trial proceeds
to the presentation of evidencefirst by the prosecu-
tor and then by the defense.
7-15
|