| |
unless they are admitted according to the Military Rules
of Evidence
l The right to plead not guilty or guilty
l The right to cross-examine witnesses and have
the SCM officer cross-examine witnesses on behalf of
the accused
l The right to call witnesses and produce evidence
with the assistance of the SCM officer, if necessary
l The right to testify on the merits or to remain
silent with the assurance that no adverse inference will
be drawn by the SCM officer for such silence
l If any findings of guilty are announced, the right
to remain silent, to make an unsworn statement, oral or
written or both, to testify, and to introduce evidence in
extenuation and mitigation
. The right to object to trial by SCM
l The maximum sentence that the SCM officer
may adjudge if found guilty of the offense(s) alleged
The maximum punishment at a SCM includes the
following:
E-4 and belowThe jurisdictional maximum
sentence that an SCM may adjudge in the case of an
accused who, at the time of trial is in paygrade E-4 or
below, extends to (1) reduction to the lowest paygrade
(E-1); (2) forfeiture of two-thirds of 1 months pay
(CA may apportion collection over no more than 3
months); (3) a fine not to exceed two-thirds of 1
months pay; (4) confinement not to exceed 1 month;
(5) hard labor without confinement not to exceed 45
days (instead of confinement); and (6) restriction to
specified limits for 2 months. If the accused is at-
tached to or embarked in a vessel and is in paygrade
E-3 or below, he or she may be sentenced to serve 3
days confinement on bread and water/diminished ra-
tions and 24 days confinement instead of 30 days
confinement.
E-5 and aboveThe jurisdictional maximum that
an SCM could impose in the case of an accused who,
at the time of trial is in paygrade E-5 or above, extends
to (1) reduction, but only to the next inferior pay-
grade; (2) restriction to specified limits for 2 months;
and (3) forfeiture of two-thirds of 1 months pay.
Unlike NJP, where an E-4 may be reduced to E-3 and
then awarded restraint punishments imposable
only upon an E-3 or below, at SCM, an E-5 cannot
be sentenced to confinement or hard labor without
confinement even if a reduction to E-4 has also been
adjudged.
Advice to Accused Regarding Counsel
While the MCM, 1984, created no statutory right
to detailed military defense counsel at an SCM, the
CA may still permit the presence of such counsel if
the accused can obtain such counsel. However, the
MCM, 1984, has created a limited right to civilian
defense counsel at SCMs. The accused has a right to
hire a civilian lawyer and have that lawyer appear at
trial, if such appearance will not necessarily delay the
proceedings and if military exigencies do not prevent
it. The accused must, however, bear the expense in-
volved. If the accused wishes to retain civilian coun-
sel, the SCM officer should allow him or her a
reasonable time to do so.
An accused has no right to military counsel at an
SCM. However, if an accused was not given an oppor-
tunity to consult with counsel before accepting an
SCM, the SCM will be inadmissible at a later trial by
court-martial. The term independent counsel means a
lawyer qualified within the meaning of Article 27(b),
UCMJ, who, in the course of regular duties, does not
act as the principal legal advisor to the CA.
To be admissible at a later trial by court-martial,
evidence of an SCM at which an accused was not
actually represented by counsel must affirmatively
demonstrate that:
l
l
l
the accused was advised of his or her right to
confer with counsel before deciding to accept
trial by SCM;
the accused either exercised his or her right to
confer with counsel or made a voluntary, know-
ing, and intelligent waiver; and
the accused voluntarily, knowingly, and intel-
ligently waived his or her right to refuse an
SCM.
If an accused has been properly advised of his or
her right to consult with counsel and to refuse an
SCM, his or her elections and/or waiver in this regard
are made in writing and are signed by the accused.
Use a form similar to that shown in figure 7-1 to
record the advice/waiver. It should be made on a page
13 of the accuseds service record with a copy at-
tached to the record of trial. The Acknowledgement of
Rights and Waiver, properly completed, contains all
the necessary advice to an accused. When it is prop-
erly executed, it will establish a voluntary, knowing,
7-5
|