| |
The advice of the SJA includes a written and
signed statement that sets forth that persons opinions
regarding the following:
l
l
l
l
Whether each specification on the charge sheet
alleges an offense under the UCMJ
Whether each allegation is substantiated by the
evidence indicated in the Article 32 report of
investigation
Whether a court-martial would have jurisdic-
tion over the accused and the offense(s)
The action to be taken by the CA
The SJA is personally responsible for the pretrial
advice and must make an independent and informed
appraisal of the charges and evidence to render the
advice. Another person may prepare the advice, but
the SJA is responsible for it and must sign it person-
ally.
The advice need not set forth the underlying
analysis or rationale for its conclusions. Ordinarily,
the charge sheet, forwarding letter and endorsements,
and report of investigation are sent along with the
pretrial advice. In addition, the pretrial advice should
include, when appropriate, a brief summary of the
evidence; discussion of significant aggravating, ex-
tenuating, or mitigating factors; and any previous rec-
ommendations, by commanders or others who have
forwarded the charges, for disposition of the case.
There is no legal requirement to include such informa-
tion and failure to do so is not an error. Lastly, it
should be noted that the legal conclusions reached by
the SJA are binding on the CA whereas the recom-
mendation is not.
THE GENERAL COURT-MARTIAL
TRIAL
A GCM may try any person subject to the Code
for any offense made punishable under the Code.
GCMs also may try any person for a violation of
Articles 83, 104, and 106. Upon a finding of guilty of
an offense made punishable by the Code, GCMs may,
within limits prescribed in the MCM, adjudge any
punishment authorized under R.C.M. 1003. The death
penalty may not be adjudged if not specifically
authorized for the offense by the Code or the case has
been referred as noncapital. The GCM composed only
of a military Judge does not have jurisdiction to try
any person for any offense for which the death penalty
may be adjudged unless the case has been referred as
noncapital. In essence, this means the death penalty
may not be imposed by a military judge, it must be
imposed by a court composed of members.
TRIAL PROCEDURES
As you have just learned, there are
to convening a GCM. Once an Article
(ion has been conducted and a case is
prerequisites
32 investiga-
referred to a
GCM, the actual procedure of the trial is the same as
that of an SPCM. However, there are some differ-
ences between a GCM and an SPCM in composition
and qualification of parties.
A GCM is composed of a military judge and not
less than five members or except for in capital cases a
military judge alone, if requested and approved.
The military judge of a GCM is designated for
such duties by the Judge Advocate General, certified
to be qualified for duty as a military judge of a GCM
and is assigned and directly responsible to the Judge
Advocate General.
There is no difference in the qualifications of any
person who may be assigned to act as a member in a
GCM. The only difference is that there must be a
minimum of five members appointed. If the accused
elects to be tried by a court composed of enlisted
members, then the GCM must consist of at least two
enlisted members.
As in an SPCM, a DC or associate DC must be
certified under Article 27(b), UCMJ, to perform the
duties of DC at a GCM. However, unlike the SPCM
the TC only need be a commissioned officer, in a
GCM the TC must be a person certified by the Judge
Advocate General under Article
such duties.
SUMMARY
27(b) to perform
This chapter has given you the insight needed to
understand how summary, special, and general court-
martials work. As a Legal man you will be involved in
court-martial proceedings whether it is from the con-
vening authority level or at a NLSO where you will be
involved in some aspect of the trial proceedings itself.
The information found in this chapter should become
second nature to you as you gain experience in the
Legalman rating and process cases for court-martial.
7-30
|